Discuss Pooch's answer to: Should Transgenders compete in beauty contests?

23-year-old Miss Universe Canada finalist was disqualified from the competition after it was discovered she had undergone sexual reassignment surgery Do you think Transponders should be allowed to ...

No female that has had any kind of reconstructive surgury should be allowed to compete in "beauty" contests....transgendered or not.

Liked this answer? Tell your friends about it

7 Comments About This Answer

Add your comment
 
Anonymous Comment

Reconstructive? Or cosmetic? What if a woman had to have a mastectomy and had reconstructive surgery but didn't change her bust size, just rebuilt it to what it was. Wouldn't that be ok?

 
Chaplain John

I would not question the motive of a woman who had reconstructive surgery done.  I have good reason to question the motive of a man who pays such hideous fees to make himself appear female.

 
Pooch

One cannot understand the "motive of a man who pays such hideous fees to make himself appear female" unless SHE has lived within a male body (vice verse for female body/male brain).  Research facts, sweety.....  FYI.....Being gay is not the same thing as being transgendered.  YOU should have more compassion.....

 
Melvin Whitcombe Thinks this answer is Not Helpful:

Amen on reconstructive surgery to correct the effects of a disfiguring injury.  Deep enough scars can make it impossible to move.  Cleft Palate and facial injuries require surgical correction.

 

The severely disabling neuroses of persons who think that they are the other gender is not best solved on the operating table but in the office of a counselor who can resolve the underlying problems.

 

Invariably people who get sex change surgery find out that it was the worst of mistakes and try to have it reversed, only to find that there is no way to do so.

 
Anonymous Comment

Rocmike 7 straight hours of posting under your Melvin alias. You need help and a life.

 
Pooch

Melvin:  How have you "defeated atheism again"?  Also, please post where you found the facts that "Invariably people who get sex change surgery find out that it was the worst of mistakes and try to have it reversed".  Thanks in advance, sweety.

 
Anonymous Comment

This is the spirit of Chaplain John  speaking to you from hell channeled through, Melvin Whitcombe The Yuma Philosopher.  I was in a plane crash, Repent and Believe in Jesus Christ NOW, when you die it's to late, gotta go.

 

 


Add Your Comment (or add your own answer)
Insert: