Is Steven Tyler a good judge for American Idol?

Do you think that Steven Tyler is a good judge on American Idol? Do you think he will be asked back next season? 

Liked this question? Tell your friends about it

4 Answers

Order by
Oldest to Newest
Newest to Oldest
Votes

Yes, I think he's doing a good job.

I agree with Linda, I think his analysis is quite good.

Broadcast Studio Pro

Plus don't you think he adds a bit of spice and fun to the critiques? 

A lot better than (your in it to win it) randy Jackson

I don't wish to be argumentative ,but I disagree with the Islamic belief that I should be killed! " If radical atheists decided they needed to kill believers to ensure their place in nothingness, I'd be criticizing that too."

Related Questions

Other people asked questions on similar topics, check out the answers they received:

Asked: What did you think of Steven Tyler on American ...

What did you think of Steven Tyler on American Idol?

Asked: Jennifer Lopez Signs A Contract With American Idol ...

Jennifer Lopez has officially linked a deal with American Idol to be a celebrity judge for a cool $12 million. Do you think she'll be a diva in her role? How do you think this dancer/actress will ...

Asked: Why was Pia Toscano eliminated from American Idol?

Pia Toscano eliminated?? Why? Is she a bad singer? Not charismatic enough? Victim of a voting glitch? I'm still shocked. Maybe you'll have some answers?