Originated From
AOL Search

Socrates and Memory

Can you provide a good explanation of Socrate's theory on memory?

Liked this question? Tell your friends about it

3 Answers

Order by
Oldest to Newest
Newest to Oldest
Votes

A combination of Isaac Newton's and Kant's opinion corresponds to the following worldview: God communicates with us by means of two sources of information the Bible and Nature. The knowledge we acquire from these sources is based on concepts and intuition of the senses. Both depend on the structure of our intelligence, which has some innate fundamental, innate concepts built in a priori, that is even before our senses actually experience them. When we have the impression that we really grasped something this simply means that there is a perfect fit between our a priori concepts and experience. That is why Socrates called his way of teaching the art of the midwife (mayeutics): everything is already inside you in the form of concepts. These concepts are empty    and meaningless to you without the impressions of the senses. You give birth to them so that you can become aware of them, precisely by the experience of the senses. When there is a good match you have the impression that you have grasped it. In fact, Plato would say that you just remembered what was innate in you. A materialist would say that it was impressed in your genes.

A clash of ideas is not a catastrophe, it is an opportunity. Only its constructive conclusions should be allowed to leave the academic framework.

The idea of Socrates that knowledge is recollection makes no sense when you think it through.  If knowledge is recalling what we already know, how did we learn it in the first place in order to recollect it?  The "aha" of insight is not sense perception but is also not recollection (although once we have it we can recall it).  Recollection is not a bad model for insight; it can take us a long way before it breaks down.  Seeing insight as the perception of eternal forms (which are more real than the entities that embody them) is also not a bad model.  These two models and their inadequacies may perhaps lead us to realize that in the last analysis we do not have enough insight into insight to know what it is.  This understanding makes us wiser than those who believe the models.  

Say whatever you want, just as long as it doesn't keep you from seeing the way things are. And when you see that, there is much you wont say.

Socrates' theory (which is really only a literary attribution by Plato, who is believed as the author of the dialogue) depends on the fact that knowledge is learned a priori and not a posteriori, which, if you read the Meno - (wikipedia here the dialogue where the theory is mentioned - he attempts to prove from the slave that he turned within himself to learn and not from outside.

The defense of this thesis requires lengthy analysis on certain sections of the Theaetetus, Republic, Phaedo, and Timaeus among other dialogues written by Plato

Related Questions

Other people asked questions on similar topics, check out the answers they received:

Asked: What is the most stark contrast that differs ...

As much as i know, western philosophy is partly built on the most principal tenets of abrahamic faith and monotheistic belief. So, in the process of development, it strongly presses on ...

Asked: Is life not campy enough?

Is life not campy enough?

Asked: Is it wildly optimistic to say that if life ...

Is it wildly optimistic to say that if life gives you lemons make lemonade? I'd put it much more bluntly because we get nothing anywhere near as good a lemons. It should be if life gives you manure ...

More Questions

Lately, I have been having problems with memory. I ...

Yes, you are onto it, stress is one of the major ffactors affecting memory. Why not write a list of all the things that stress you out in a week (unless list writing stresses you out) and sit down to see what you might do about them. Diet is really important too. Lots of fresh foods are good for ...

Memorial co.

From your topic it looks like you know the cemetery in question? Have you called them? They may have a computer listing so they can narrow down your search and tell you what section he is in. If you live in this city go search yourself. If you live in a different city, here is a web site for you ...

Do the memory foam pillows help to reduce snoring in those who are prone

Memory foam pillows are perfectly capable to reduce snoring and known as one of the best snoring solutions . By providing support to user’s neck and back, it comforts him and encourages healthy sleeping hours. This pillow is designed in such a way that aligns body spine and neck. Due to such design ...

Sad memorys

The day you first came on.