Can you respond to these counterarguments against requiring ALL adults to report suspected/witnessed child abuse?

Can you respond to these counterarguments that require ALL adults to report suspected/witnessed child abuse?


1. Requiring all adults is impossible to enforce
2. It would lead to false reports and tear families apart
3. If the law were perfectly followed the police and courts would be pushed beyond their limits because too many abusers exist.
4. Requiring all adults to report abuse is an enforcement of reality/violation of freedom of choice, and the government shouldn't enforce moral platforms or violate people's autonomy.

Liked this question? Tell your friends about it


All of your feeble arguments could be said about most every law. In your view all laws would apply only if the law was broken in view of a law enforcement officer. What kind of a society would we create if nobody ever spoke up. I wonder if maybe you have something to report but are looking for a way out.

Sure I'll give up my guns. But you'll have to pry them from my cold dead fimgers. "A government that fears arms in the hands of people should also fear rope." By Nathan Bedford Forrest "Gun control laws increase the power of government and the criminal element over the average citizen and serve no other purpose." By Robert E. Lee

Related Questions

Other people asked questions on similar topics, check out the answers they received:

Asked: RI Probate law related

is there a tort cause of action in rhode island law related to anticipated inheritance. I.E> I anticipate by way of a 1974 WILL that I will receive 1/3 of all assets at time of death; however other 2 ...

Asked: What is an example of how corporate culture ...

what is an example of how corporate culture influences the ethical behavior of an organization in a negative way?

Asked: Do we have 1913 laws in 2013? I'm not against ...

Do we have 1913 laws in 2013? I'm not against slowing people down in the least, but you have to let people breathe. Our laws don't even allow that.

More Questions

Finger lakes times Man charger because of Robert Colton reporting him.

Looks to me like some body got snitched out, cause the snitch cared enough about the crook to get him the help he needs not to get stuck into a life of crime -- and every thing that comes with it. You know, guilt, bitterness, a scorched conscience, and stuck with that forever. Look back on it, and ...

How do I report abuse on a cell phone?

Hi Karen, You can reply "block" to the text messages from these senders. This will block your phone number from being texted by these individuals.

Reporting abuse

how can I report abuse on odnaklasnik if somone took my picture and opened a site with my name and is violating my right and writing insults

Friends Suspected of Child Abuse

This seems to be bothering you. I would anonymously call Child Protective Services.