Help with my Sister-In-Law!

My wife and I had been married 2 months and moved into her sister's house to save money and have more room. Three months later my wife I had a stupid argument that blew way out of proportion. She suggested seperating (not the first threat) as a way to resolve our problems. As a result, I was so angry that after she left the room (I was now alone) I smashed my favorite drinking glass on the kitchen floor of my SIL house. I know I was wrong to do so and felt terrible for disrespecting her property. The next day, SIL told my wife I couldn't live there anymore so the next morning I moved back to our old apartment by myself. The day after that, SIL demanded my key back even though my wife and 2 dogs were still there. After a couple days of cool down, I wrote a page long apology letter to my wife, SIL and their parents. SIL never responded and told wife I am not allowed in her house without wife being there and she must be notified before my arrival. I am a 24 year old 5'7'', 130lbs and look like I'm 16. SIL (30 years old, 6', 180 lbs) still tells wife and rest of family that she feels threatened and unsafe in my presence. I have never hit/threatened a person in my life and they all sympethize with her. I understand that women would view the instance as violent where a man would not but give me a f***ing break, what a bunch of sh*t. I can't even go over there to feed my dogs in the afternoon or pack up my stuff without supervision even though no one is there. What a crock of sh*t! I work evenings and when SIL got a choc lab pup, I watched it every afternoon and fed it until I left for work. Lately when wife visits me, SIL tells her she has to bring our dogs with because it's not fair that she has to watch our dogs for a couple hours. She makes it a big deal even though they are both 2 years old, trained well and need no supervision. My wife gets upset because we (SIL and self) put her in the middle of everything even though it is only her sister that will not act like an adult. MY GOD, PLEASE HELP. I love her family and do not want to sour the relationship any farther but what can I do! I even took it upon myself to go out and buy/read a book on anger management which by the way has changed my life for the better. Maybe she just needs more time.....

Liked this question? Tell your friends about it

3 Answers

Order by
Oldest to Newest
Newest to Oldest

Hi Ag's&h's,
Welcome to Yedda.  I hope you are an open person so I'll be able to answer you without sugar coating my words.   You made several mistakes. 
1.  Being "just married" you should spent at
     least one year on your own (to built the
     ties / bond betwen the two of you).  It is
     much more important than saving
2.  Before moving to your SIL you (both)
     had to decide that all your disputes /
     arguements will be delt behind "closed
     doors" (and never involve her !).
3.  You didn't realized how much your SIL
     "invested" in you (accepting you with the
     2 dogs).   And she axpects you to return
     (in terms of: respecting her, being
     gratefull and thanking her).  You did the
4.  You HAD to controll your anger.  No way 
     to react like that.  It is simply
5.  She is intimidated.  It's not a matter of
     size, age or height...... Be considerative
     and understandable and accept all her 
     "new laws".... that is the "penalty" or
     your behavior.
6.  The best you can do is:
     a.  Discuss it with your wife. 
     b.  Suggest that you orgenize a meeting
          (you two and your SIL).
     c.  Set a date, prepare exactly what you
          are going to say (be sensetive and
          carefull in choosing your words).
     d.  Say that you made a mistake, you
          regret, it will never happen again,
          and you ask her to appologize you. 
     e.  Tell her you'll accept any "new rules"
          she sets. 
     f.  Don't forget to mention that you love
         her and the entire family.
     g. Say that you are going to take classes
         to controll your temper (and do it !).
     g. If she agree, OK..... If not than take
          your wife and move out.
7.  Invest hard (and much) in the relations
     between you and your wife.   It's not 
     going to be easy !.    Ifv you don't do it
     you might (G-d forbid) loose her. 
Best regards,


Love is the battery of life....

Why don't they trust you?  What does your wife want to do? Does she trust you? Does she want a divorse? Is she going to move back in with you or stay with her sister?  Drama happens.  Especially when you LIVE with another family member.  Rule of THUMB~  Married couple is 2, not 3 or 4 or 5... 2.  You live with NO one but your self.  All the money in the world can't take away a great relationship, but, the money you saved living with SIL, wasn't worth the situation you are in now.  I'd say just find out your facts and act on them.  Don't take dogs to a shelter.  They will be killed there, unless it is a no kill shelter.  Find them a suitable home if you find that you need to... but get your act together and get your wife back or move on with out her.


If you don't WANT to, and you don't HAVE to... DON'T!

The way i see it from what you wrote and i know it is a diffacult decesision to make but it sounds to me that her family is more involved than you think as they may be giving her ideas then she tells you only what you dont want to hear. As this is the familys whole thing is to seperate the two of you up. than as you stated SIL demanded my key back even though my wife and 2 dogs were still there. After a couple days of cool down, I wrote a page long apology letter to my wife, SIL and their parents. SIL never responded and told wife I am not allowed in her house without wife being there and she must be notified before my arrival.still tells wife and rest of family that she feels threatened and unsafe in my presence. I think if you look at it you may have answered your own question. As to much family involvement on her side and by SIL getting involved and there not looking at the whole picture. As you married her not the family as they are inlaws only are her family and if you want not yours. Also keep your family out of it also as this is you and your wife's to work out between the two of you. Yes i am gowing to use a very old wording that has been around for years ( Two familys cannot live under the same roof at one time and get aloung ). But if your wife insists of a seperation then that is her idea but watch your 6 as some one else may be involved in it...LOL

Equal justice for All The law works but the system needs changed, We all abide by the law but sometime it failes us. The same with the goverment. God bless the USA, Brign our troops HOME safely, To the men who did not get the credit they deserve, MAY GOD WATCH OVER OUR SERVICE MEN.

Related Questions

Other people asked questions on similar topics, check out the answers they received:

Asked: How to get well with them ?

Now I live with my brother , sister-in-low and another girl. Everyone has a work. But my sister-in-law has two time skedules, one day normal, one day from afternoon to night. Others are nomal but a ...

Asked: Get my brother to move on!!

My whole family hates my brothers' wife. All she does is manipulate him. She cheated, left him, and now has returned. How can I convince him to move on?

Asked: Robbed

female juvenile crimes In or around St. Charles Catholic School 55418 Has anyone reported being robbed on holloween 2008 after letting a young female in to use the bathroom, while tick or treating in ...

Ask a Question... We'll forward it to people who know

More Questions


Hi Timmy: So I can better assist you, could you please provide me with additional information? Do you get an error message? If you get an error message, could you tell me what it says?

Help me find my mothers lost sister please!

Have you tried these websites?

What is an installment agreement and will it help?

For me, it is when you need a new faucet on your sink because the old one sank in Glacier Bay. So you call me and ask me to do this. I say OK. We have an installment agreement. And you pay me in full upon completion of the install.

How can a DUI attorney help?

DUI charges nowadays is not a joke; in some states, it's a criminal offense that could not only suspend your license, but can earn you jail time AND expensive fees. Not to mention driving school. An experienced DUI attorney like can defend your case properly ...