If I finished an audio-book, can I say I read it?

If I just finished an audio-book, can I say I read it? Or when asked I have to say "oh, yeah - I listened to / heard that book"?

Liked this question? Tell your friends about it

7 Answers

Order by
Oldest to Newest
Newest to Oldest
Votes

Generally speaking .... Yes, I think it is ok to say you "read it" if you heard it all, especially if you mean outside of academic/school setting (where it might or might not really matter).

Keep on reading! Smile

Rob

ROBonYEDDA@YAHOOl.com Wisdom comes from Study, Travel & Life experiences! MY YEDDA CONCEPT IS: Good questions deserve good answers; Poor ones deserve a quick/poor answer. Dumb or silly, deserves same ... and the occasional but inevitable Idiots are best just ignored.

So, let's say you just listened to the complete audio book version of The Lovely Bones and your co-worker asks, "Have you read it yet?"

I don't think you need to explain that you listened to it, rather than 'read' it (visually impaired people don't clarify, why should you?) but if you don't want to go there, why not just say, "I'm familiar with it" and then turn the conversation to a discussion of your favorite part of the story?

Turn off the television and teach your children how to think. ~ Believe none of what you hear and half of what you see. (B. Franklin) ~ I do not respond in Comments ~ Trespassers will be eaten. Cowards, idiots and spammers will be shot on sight. ~ YeddaHeads

Sure you can. I also believe that it is not honest, but the honesty issue probably only matters in school. In fact, if a friend asked you if you read it and you said that you did not but you listened to it, I can see your friend taking exception to your nitpicking.

 

I suppose that if you read a textual book out loud that you could say that you listened to it.

 

I'm so glad that we can have meaningful discussions like this when our country is going up in flames.

 

Just out of curiosity, what was it that caused you to ask this?

Keep close to Nature's heart... climb a mountain or spend a week in the woods. Wash your spirit clean.* Victims of circumstance owe it to fate. Victims of choice owe it to themselves.*One of the widest gaps in human experience is the gap between what we say we want to be and our willingness to discipline ourselves to get there.

You did not read the book, someone read the book to you. Do you go around claiming to have read the lyrics of all the songs you've ever heard too? Ridiculous.

 

<a href="" rel="nofollow" cl="http://mcdonaldscouponsguide.com" class="comlink">McDonalds Coupons</a> are a real life saver!...NOT

If you're asking if your experience counts, undoubtedly my answer would be yes.

I think listening to an audio book is an entirely different experience than sitting down and reading the book, but to say that one is better than the other would be a bit silly. Personally I tend to retain more if I read it as opposed to listening, but I'm sure there are people that find the opposite to be true. Some works, like Shakespeare beg to be read aloud, and I think you could gain a lot by hearing it.

If you're doing this for a class in most cases I would recommend actually reading the book and annotating the text. Personally I find it hard to quote passages and analyze text that is not in front of me. Heck if you have a unabridged copy of both the audio and written version you could do both simultaneously, now that would be fun.

Check out my blog:<a href="" rel="nofollow" cl="http://gestclarinetist.wordpress.com/" class="comlink">Gest Clarinetist</a>

Thanks to all for your answers.
There is no deep reason for my asking. I just think that it's an interesting question in the etiquette of the digital world in which we live.

I have a long commute to work (32 miles ~ 50km) each way, and listened to my first audio book (The Facebook Effect) in about 2 weeks.

It is a completely different experience from reading, I must agree. It was also interesting because the author narrated the book, and he speaks at the end of the narration about his experience doing so and the difficulties and challenges it presented to read it out loud and tell the story.

Thanks again for all your answers!

Best, Itay.

Be sure to check out my blog! <a href="" rel="nofollow" cl="http://www.itaysworld.com/blog" class="comlink">itaysworld.com/blog</a> <a href="" rel="nofollow" cl="http://itaysworld.com/reefcam/" class="comlink">Click here to see</a> my 180 gallon Reef Tank WebCam!


I think listening to it would be more apt. But that's just me.

Related Questions

Other people asked questions on similar topics, check out the answers they received:

Asked: How to preserve an old book 1915 of human bondage

I have an original copy of human bondage1915 how is the best way to preserve it?

Asked: Old book 1915 of human bondage what is best way to ...

what is the best way to store an old book from 1915

Asked: Value of author signed book to famous baseball ...

"Final Verdict" book value, signed by the author Adela Rogers St Johns and presented to a very famous now deceased baseball player.